Most people are aware of Paul Revere’s midnight ride in April 1775 due to the poem by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow and the hanging of two lanterns in the Old North Church steeple preceding his journey.  We at the Hingham Historical Society were delighted to learn that this event has a Hingham connection.

Thaxter Mansion, North Street, Hingham

One of the men responsible for hanging the two lanterns was John Pulling, Jr. a vestryman of Old North and a friend of Paul Revere. John was born in 1737 in Boston and was a trader by occupation. He married his first wife, Annis Lee, in Manchester in 1768. They had two children, a daughter and son both named for their parents.

Abigail (Smith) Thaxter

John’s wife Annis died in 1771. This is where the Hingham connection comes in. John married his second wife, Sarah Thaxter McBean (17461843) in January 1773. She was the daughter of Major Samuel Thaxter (1723-1771) of Hingham, a trader and veteran of the French and Indian War, and Abigail Smith (1722-1807), daughter of Samuel and Bethia (Chipman) Smith of Sandwich. Sarah grew up in the Thaxter mansion on North Street, the site of today’s St. Paul’s Church. A portrait of Sarah’s mother, Abigail Smith hangs in our Old Ordinary museum.

Pulling Tablet, Old North Church

This was Sarah’s second marriage as well. She was the widow of Duncan McBean, a West Indies planter from a family of Scottish traders. The McBeans had no surviving children. Records show that Sarah and John Pulling had three known children: Sarah (1773), Martha (ca 1780) and Richard (bef. 1782). During the Revolutionary War John served as a Captain and Commander of Ordinance Stores. On April 19 when he heard he was wanted by the British for questioning in his role aiding Revere, he, Sarah and their children fled Boston in a fishing boat, making their way to Hull. This event is memorialized on a tablet on the Old North Church. When they returned to the North End of Boston after the British evacuated in March 1776, they found their house ransacked and all their property gone. 

121-123 Main Street, Hingham

After John’s death in 1787 Sarah and her family (including the two children from John’s first marriage) returned to Hingham, where they lived until Sarah married for the third time to Thomas Reed of Abington in 1793. It is unknown where in Hingham Sarah and the children lived during that five-year period as Sarah’s childhood home, the Thaxter Mansion had been sold to Elisha Leavitt, Jr. in 1770. Perhaps Sarah and the children lived with

Parlor at 137 Main Street, Hingham

one of her younger brothers who remained in Hingham? Dr. Thomas Thaxter lived at 121 Main Street and Henry Thaxter lived at 137 Main Street. Both houses still stand today. After marrying Thomas Reed, Sarah resided in Abington until her death in 1843 at age 97.