The great thing about poking around in an archive as rich as ours at the Hingham Historical Society is that connections are there to be made. Half the story might be in one document—and then the other half pops up. A prior post on this blog (“An Appeal to Town Meeting”) was about the address of an unnamed 18th century farmer to Hingham’s Town Meeting. The farmer had complained that he was unable to drive his livestock to pasture at the Great Lots, or bring off any produce, because another Hingham farmer, Thomas Hersey, had built a stone wall across a public way. The farmer had came to Town Meeting armed with evidence that, he claimed, proved that one hundred years previously the Town had authorized the laying out of a road to ensure the access to the very same Great Lots now blocked by Mr. Hersey. And there the story ended. The documents we were looking at were from the Hersey Family papers, and they left the identity of the petitioner and the outcome of the dispute unknown.
But it turned out that the rest of the story was nearby, in our Thaxter Family papers, because the unhappy petitioner was John Thaxter, Sr., who left a memorandum describing the resolution reached at Town Meeting, together with the “true copy” of the 17th century Town Meeting vote upon which he relied. John Thaxter presented the dispute to Town Meeting on December 17, 1794. He presented evidence that in June 1694, almost exactly 100 years previously, Josiah Loring had complained to the Town Meeting that he could not access his own pasture at the Great Lots. The solution he had proposed, which was accepted by the Town, was the laying out of a public way between Broad Cove Lane and Goles Lane (the “Turnpike”) adjacent to the Great Lots and the Squirrel Hill Lots. According to Thaxter’s memorandum, written the next day, here is what happened:
At a Legal town meeting in Hingham June ye 19th 1794. The within votes of the Town [i.e., the 1694 record] were presented to the Town by John Thaxter as a memorial that the high way from Goles Lane to Broad Cove Street which has been passed & repassed on time immemorial is now stopped up by Thomas Hearsy erecting a stone wall across the same whereby said Thaxter is deprived from going to his pasture at great Lotts in a great measure. As the meeting was thin the town thought there was a probability of said Thaxter & Hearsy settling the difficulty subsisting between them and they labored for an accommodation. Said Thaxter then made said Hearsy a proposal. As both of them had said they would not remove the wall, that if said Hearsy would send a hand he would another to remove the wall, which said Hearsy agreed to. Then said Thaxter withdrew the memorial and nothing further was acted by the Town. The wall was removed the next day.
So, with some encouragement (or pressure) from their neighbors, John Thaxter and Thomas Hersey settled their dispute, agreeing to share the job of removing the stone wall which Thaxter had proved was an obstruction on a public way.
Thaxter and Hersey were contemporaries, born two years apart in the early 1730s. Hersey lived on Lincoln Street, Thaxter on South Street; both spent their entire lives in Hingham, except for military service and Thaxter’s years at Harvard College. They must have known each other very well. We don’t know what their personal relationship was or how this incident fit into it. They have, however, provided us a glimpse into how local land use disputes were handled in a long-ago era.